How to Hire Right the First Time

Have you ever thought you hired the workplace version of John Wayne, only to find out youʼve been duped and ended up with a Woody Allen? Poor hiring decisions are costly mistakes that can range as high as 300% of an employeeʼs base salary. Financial losses include expenses associated with hiring and training, low employee morale and decreased productivity. Plus, poor hiring choices frequently lead to damaged client relationships, loss of new business and business in general, unemployment and more. The bottom line is that bad hiring decisions can make or break a business.

Why mis-hires occur

The two most common hiring traps are hiring in a hurry and hiring the résumé rather than the person. Companies that donʼt have succession plans or fail to practice cross-training often rush to relieve the pain of the empty chair.

Businesses that ignore the hiring process in the interest of expediting it are far more susceptible to missing important clues that could prevent a poor hiring decision. For example, job seeker studies show that a substantial percentage embellish their credentials with one or more “tall tales”; a third of them outright lie. From reporting academic degrees never achieved and embellishing roles to listing completely fictitious positions, many of todayʼs job seekers will do whatever they can to appear qualified.

A third and very common trap is to hire on the basis of job descriptions. These typically list a subjective interpretation of required skills and experience. By highlighting only hard skills, they leave out the most critical elements such as key performance objectives, behaviors, values, character traits and soft competencies  —  the defining criteria that lead to effective performance.

With the war on talent in full force, there is tremendous pressure on hiring managers to keep their organizations fully staffed and productive. But how does one meet these demands without falling into hiring traps? After more than two decades as a recruiter, staffing agency owner, and leader of the KeenAlignment strategic hiring and retention initiative, Iʼve developed an arsenal of practical tips and insider tools that empower business owners and HR executives alike with the ability to make informed decisions about their most important resource — their people. Today, I share these with you in a simple step-by-step format.

What is an internal hiring process and how do we create one?

If you hire someone you donʼt really know, for a position you have not thoroughly defined, chances are that neither the person nor the position will deliver. Hiring the right people requires implementation of a comprehensive internal hiring process that selects the best and eliminates the rest. And it all starts with benchmarking. Whether you are benchmarking the role, the top performers in that role, or key traits of the best performers in the company as a whole, the first step is creating the model of what “right” looks like. Companies that take the time to do so fully understand not only who they need, but also why they need them. These are the companies that excel in the employee-selection process and the capacity to build a dream team.

Before you evaluate your immediate needs, evaluate the company and team. This is called the Internal Human Capital Inventory and Assessment, and it involves:

Article Continues Below

  1. Evaluating your core culture:
    1. Acknowledge and prorate your core values
    2. Assess the character quotient of your company
    3. Identify the non-negotiable character traits or core values for your company.
  2. Evaluating your current team:
    1. Identify your key players and what innate abilities and traits make them successful
    2. Identify whatʼs working on the team and what isnʼt
    3. Identify what elements are missing on the team that would make a positive difference.
  3. Implementing a system for evaluating and selecting new hires and internal promotions:
    1. Establish and cross-train to hiring protocol
    2. Create companywide candidate-screening ground rules
    3. Create a Comprehensive Position Requirement (CPR) for every role
    4. Validate, select and utilize the right assessment tools
    5. Create behavioral-based interview models for each role in the company
    6. Establish a decision-making matrix.

Hiring techniques that save money

With a treetop look at your company and a foundation in place to grow from, itʼs time to look at each role on a tree-trunk level. Focus on the needs of the business and how each role is attached to the key performance indicators of the company as a whole. When you are clear on the performance objectives for each role in the company and how those affect the big picture of service, sales, retention and profitability, it is much easier to determine who the best person is for each role. Here are some specific holistic hiring techniques:

  1. Hire right the first time:
    1. Thoroughly define each role in your company
    2. Define specific success outcomes that are expected in the role
    3. Isolate the CAN DO (Intellectual Quotient)
    4. Isolate the WILL DO (Emotional Quotient)
    5. Isolate the FIT IN (Character Quotient).
  2. Follow the hiring protocol:
    1. Train each hiring manager on the CPR for his/her positions
    2. Conduct a preplanned behavioral-based telephone screening
    3. Employ a cursory pre-interview assesment
    4. Formulate a position-specific interviewing guide for managers to follow
    5. Make hiring decisions according to the predetermined hiring matrix.
  3. Set up an effective ramp-up process that validates your hiring choice out of the gate:
    1. Socialization – on-boarding
    2. Manager – new employee
    3. Game plan – expectations, communication, work style.

With established hiring procedures adhered to consistently, your company will jump over and past dangerous hiring traps, turn the tables on the mishaps of poor hiring, and reap the benefits that come with having the right people in the right roles.

About the Author

Magi Graziano, as seen on NBC, is the CEO of Conscious Hiring® and Development, a speaker, employee recruitment and engagement expert and author of The Wealth of Talent. Through her expansive knowledge and captivating presentations, Magi provides her customers with actionable, practical ideas to maximize their effectiveness and ability to create high-performing teams. With more than 20 years’ experience as a top producer in the Recruitment and Search industry, she empowers and enables leaders to bring transformational thinking to the day-to-day operation. For more information on Magi please visit www.KeenAlignment.com.    

  • KunbaHR.com

    Excellent post. As a HR Manager myself I see this everyday. There is the pressure from the hiring managers to fill the open position and most candidates that I see nowadays come in without doing basic homework. While experience matters, I rather have someone who has aptitude, attitude and desire to learn and grow even though his/her resume may be less steller. Lots of organizations failed to follow thru and keep the new hire motivated even after they have found a right candidate. At KunbaHR – (https://www.kunbaHR.com) where I guest post sometime, I recently published an article about this topic. Please check it out if you can.

    https://kunbahr.com/HRBlog/?p=40

    Thank you
    Sandy Nolen – https://www.kunbaHR.com