When You Hire From the Outside, Does It Mean Your Organization Failed?

hiring

Henry Ward, the CEO of eShares, wrote a post on Medium recently titled How to Hire. It’s a great piece from an executive point of view regarding the concept of talent acquisition.

Basically, Henry feels that if your organization needs to go out and hire external talent, you’ve failed as an organization:

Hiring means we failed to execute and need help. First, let me quell a misconception. Hiring is not a consequence of success. Revenue and customers are. Hiring is a consequence of our failure to create enough leverage (see eShares 101) to grow on our own. It means we need outside help. The perfect business is a computer plugged into the internet. Starting with me, every human thereafter is overhead. And we are increasing overhead by 50 percent.

I want to repeat this point: We are increasing overhead by 50 percent because we failed to execute. It is not something to be proud of. It is humbling to go back to the labor market, hat-in-hand, asking for help…”

Yes, execs think differently than HR and Talent Acquisition

Want to know why your executives don’t respect HR? Read the above.

Executives think about the business differently than we do in HR and Talent Acquisition. I’m 100 percent sure any head of TA would believe hiring, because of business growth, equals success, not failure.

Even if you take Henry’s example of the perfect business model being a computer plugged into the Internet, one could still argue that any organization that can’t self-sustain its own growth of labor is a failure.

Think about it from a training and development point of view.

  • You hire entry level candidates and train and develop them into every part of your organization.
  • You have a succession plan.
  • If everything works perfectly, you never hire “talent” from the outside — you just hire new, clean, entry level bodies, and create your own clone army!

OK, at this point we still need to use outside bodies. I would guess at some point Google will create real, live human clones, then the process could be completely self-contained.

One CEO’s hiring philosophy

So, how does Henry Ward hire at eShares?  Here is his hiring philosophy:

  1. Hire for Strength vs Lack of Weakness;
  2. Hire for Trajectory vs Experience;
  3. Hire “Doers” vs “Tellers;”
  4. Hire Learners vs Experts;
  5. Hire Different vs Similar;
  6. Always pass on ego.

Pretty solid. Some of it might depend on your industry, company, etc. I’m not a huge believer in always hiring for difference. Difference causes conflict. In some organizations that is great, but in some organizations, that is catastrophic — just as similar, group think, etc. is bad in many cases, it’s perfect in other ones.

Article Continues Below

Sponsored Content

6 Things Your Employees Will Fail Without

Are you bringing on top candidates only to have them become average employees? Sometimes we forget how important it is to coach our employees to be successful as individuals. Learn how to identify when your employees need more engagement and how you can impact your employees’ success for the long term.
6 Things Your Employees Will Fail Without Circle

Give Henry’s article on How to Hire a read. He goes into detail on each step in his philosophy with an explanation.

It’s one of the best executive written pieces I’ve ever read on hiring.

This was originally published on Tim Sackett’s blog, The Tim Sackett Project.